Maureen's recent blog updated 20 May 2013
 Click here for blog
Click for copy of Maureen's Newsletter
|
|
17 May - 1974 Dublin and Monaghan bombings remembered
Click for An Phoblacht article
Maureen attended today's commemoration of the bombings in 1974 at the Talbot St Memorial
' . . Speaking at the commemoration, artist and activist Robert Ballagh noted recent moves by Justice Minister Alan Shatter regarding pardons for Irish Defence Forces deserters during World War Two. Ballagh said he welcomed such moves as signs of reconciliation between Ireland and Britain but noted: “Reconciliation is a two-way street.”
He called for pressure to be put on the British Government to release its own files on the attacks, something he has consistently refused to do. . . . .'
17 May Good Friday Agreement Motion
Click to hear & read Maureen's speech
Maureen was speaking on Private Members' Motion, ' . . . Regarding Ms Marian Price, how could a royal prerogative of mercy that received significant coverage when given be lost so suddenly? She is the only female being held in isolation in a male jail. Her medical treatment leaves much to be desired. These are abuses of her human rights. Her hearing with the Parole Commissioners is repeatedly postponed. She has been held two years on the basis of allegations.
Equally disturbing is the case of Mr. Martin Corey, who has been in jail for three years having had his licence revoked on the basis of allegations. Following a judicial review, the judge opted to release him, but the Secretary of State prevented that from happening. He is long overdue a parole review. It will not be held until July. This is internment without trial. In a democracy, due process should be followed. Level a charge, bring a person to court and let him or her have a say. If there is a conviction, it can be appealed. Otherwise, the person serves time. So-called evidence is being produced, but it will be closed. Barristers and solicitors will effectively be going into the case blindfolded. . . '
Equally disturbing is the case of Mr. Martin Corey, who has been in jail for three years having had his licence revoked on the basis of allegations. Following a judicial review, the judge opted to release him, but the Secretary of State prevented that from happening. He is long overdue a parole review. It will not be held until July. This is internment without trial. In a democracy, due process should be followed. Level a charge, bring a person to court and let him or her have a say. If there is a conviction, it can be appealed. Otherwise, the person serves time. So-called evidence is being produced, but it will be closed. Barristers and solicitors will effectively be going into the case blindfolded. . . '
16 May Dublin City Council reveals contenders for name of Liffey bridge
Click to read Irish Times online article
Great that 'Tony Gregory'
is included in short list of
names for the new Liffey bridge
is included in short list of
names for the new Liffey bridge
14 May Alcohol Sales Legislation
Read & hear debate in full
Maureen asked the Minister for Health in response to the recent statistics on the physical implications of alcohol abuse, including liver disease, as published by the Royal College of Physicians of Ireland, Reducing Alcohol Health Harm, the strategies he intends to take to tackle the abuse and misuse of alcohol particularly in the young population where alcohol/drug abuse and misuse also leads to anti-social behaviour, violence and poor relationships.
Minister of State at the Department of Health Alex White TD: . . . . I will be submitting proposals to the Government very shortly to deal with the misuse of alcohol. These proposals are based on the recommendations of the substance misuse report. These proposals are real and tangible, and cover all of the areas mentioned in the latter report including, but not limited to legislation on minimum unit pricing, which is about setting a statutory floor price per gram of alcohol; access and availability of alcohol, including separation of alcohol from other products in retail units where alcohol is sold; and advertising and sponsorship. The Cabinet committee on social policy has already considered these proposals and in developing them. My officials and I have also had frequent discussions with a number of Departments. . . .'
Minister of State at the Department of Health Alex White TD: . . . . I will be submitting proposals to the Government very shortly to deal with the misuse of alcohol. These proposals are based on the recommendations of the substance misuse report. These proposals are real and tangible, and cover all of the areas mentioned in the latter report including, but not limited to legislation on minimum unit pricing, which is about setting a statutory floor price per gram of alcohol; access and availability of alcohol, including separation of alcohol from other products in retail units where alcohol is sold; and advertising and sponsorship. The Cabinet committee on social policy has already considered these proposals and in developing them. My officials and I have also had frequent discussions with a number of Departments. . . .'
09 May Housing (Amendment) Bill 2013
Hear Maureen speak in full
Maureen was speaking on Housing bill and about the problems facing many people in Dublin Central, . . . 'First, there is a major shortage of public housing in Dublin Central, where there are more than 2,300 households on the north inner city housing list, which covers just one part of the constituency, and more than 800 of those have been on that list for over five years. At the same time, there are at least 120 vacant council housing units in the area but Dublin City Council does not have an adequate budget to bring them into use. . . . '
09 May Supporting Green Ribbon mental health initiative
Click to find out more?
1 in 4 people in Ireland have live with mental health issues which is not reflected in budgets for health services.
There is a need to keep awareness of mental health issues
and supports to the fore.
May is Green Ribbon Month in Ireland to raise awareness about Mental Health and the need for better responses.
There is a need to keep awareness of mental health issues
and supports to the fore.
May is Green Ribbon Month in Ireland to raise awareness about Mental Health and the need for better responses.
09 May Africans’ tales of acceptance in Ireland are heartening
Read Irish Times article in full
Maureen was chairing AWEPA event in the Dáil, ' . . More on another occasion about the sterling work of Awepa’s Irish section, but just to say it is among the most active in Europe, thanks in part to funding from Irish Aid that has allowed it to employ a full-time staff member, Simon Murtagh.
It was a small, relaxed gathering, sympathetically chaired by the head of Irish Awepa, Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan. There were seven African women in attendance – from Ghana, Nigeria, Congo, Somalia, Zimbabwe and Uganda – and a number of TDs. Simon and I were the only males present. . . . '
It was a small, relaxed gathering, sympathetically chaired by the head of Irish Awepa, Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan. There were seven African women in attendance – from Ghana, Nigeria, Congo, Somalia, Zimbabwe and Uganda – and a number of TDs. Simon and I were the only males present. . . . '
03 May Criminal Law Sexual Offences Amendment
Click to read & hear Maureen's speech in full
Maureen speaking on Thomas Pringle's Bill,' . . . The notion that selling or buying a body is not an abuse of human rights is where I draw the line. I believe it is an abuse. I can accept the difference of view where two consenting adults are involved but the trafficking business and buying and selling of bodies is an abuse of human rights.
It is a sad reflection on our society today that people buy sex. The increase in the number of young men who on a night out make contact with prostitutes via their mobile telephones or the Internet is alarming. I cannot help but wonder if this communication through social media, the Internet and chat rooms, and lack of emphasis on forming relationships and getting to know a person, is an indication of a lack of self esteem and confidence in young men. Another issue is instant gratification. The film "Pretty Woman" has a lot to answer for in terms of the impression it portrays of prostitution. The reality is different. Prostitution is exploitation. It certainly does not do anything for gender equality. . . . .I acknowledge the work being done by the NGOs, particularly those in Dublin Central where there is a significant level of prostitution. I refer in this regard to Ruhama and Chrysalis and the work they do on projects funded through the North Inner City Drugs Task Force.'
It is a sad reflection on our society today that people buy sex. The increase in the number of young men who on a night out make contact with prostitutes via their mobile telephones or the Internet is alarming. I cannot help but wonder if this communication through social media, the Internet and chat rooms, and lack of emphasis on forming relationships and getting to know a person, is an indication of a lack of self esteem and confidence in young men. Another issue is instant gratification. The film "Pretty Woman" has a lot to answer for in terms of the impression it portrays of prostitution. The reality is different. Prostitution is exploitation. It certainly does not do anything for gender equality. . . . .I acknowledge the work being done by the NGOs, particularly those in Dublin Central where there is a significant level of prostitution. I refer in this regard to Ruhama and Chrysalis and the work they do on projects funded through the North Inner City Drugs Task Force.'
02 May TDs call for new Luas bridge to be named after Tony Gregory
Read Irish Times article in full
'Brother of late Dublin Central deputy says he championed the regeneration of the area'
Friends and former colleagues of the late independent Dublin TD Tony Gregory have stepped up their campaign to have the new Luas bridge over the Liffey named after him.
Dublin Central TD Maureen O’Sullivan, who was elected to Mr Gregory’s former seat in the by-election following his death in 2009, introduced the group at a press event in Dublin today.
Among the supporters were TDs Finian McGrath , Catherine Murphy, Shane Ross, Joe Higgins, Mick Wallace and Thomas Pringle and Senator Terry Leyden.
Friends and former colleagues of the late independent Dublin TD Tony Gregory have stepped up their campaign to have the new Luas bridge over the Liffey named after him.
Dublin Central TD Maureen O’Sullivan, who was elected to Mr Gregory’s former seat in the by-election following his death in 2009, introduced the group at a press event in Dublin today.
Among the supporters were TDs Finian McGrath , Catherine Murphy, Shane Ross, Joe Higgins, Mick Wallace and Thomas Pringle and Senator Terry Leyden.
01 May Organ Donation Motion
Click to read & hear Maureen's speech in full
Maureen was speaking on Technical Group Motion, '. . . . . Being in that situation made me realise the importance of organ donation. I had always carried a card but that experience brought it home to me how vital it is that we are aware of the need for organ donors. I am conscious of the other lives that might have been saved if more people carried organ donor cards or if families or next of kin knew the wish of their loved ones to donate organs in the event of the situation arising. As the motion states, it is important to emphasise the incredible generosity of families who give consent for donation because it is at a time of great stress and great loss for them.
The motion refers to the Spanish and Croatian experience where there is a cost saving. Apart from the moral and ethical reasons, there is also an economic one. In Croatia, organ donation structures resulted in increased donation rates to 30 per million of the population compared with 18 per million of the population in this country. What is significant in Croatia is the network of hospital physicians responsible for organ donation within intensive care units and also that the legislation there was adjusted to include the opt-out in keeping with Spain, Belgium, Austria and Portugal. The countries that have made serious efforts on organ donation and transplants have seen major benefits, both medical and financial.. . . . I will conclude by quoting Professor Egan:
Organ donation and transplantation in Ireland is at a crossroads. With both the proposed “soft opt out” legislation and infrastructure support there is an opportunity to provide enormous benefits for generations to come. . . . ' The Motion was agreed
The motion refers to the Spanish and Croatian experience where there is a cost saving. Apart from the moral and ethical reasons, there is also an economic one. In Croatia, organ donation structures resulted in increased donation rates to 30 per million of the population compared with 18 per million of the population in this country. What is significant in Croatia is the network of hospital physicians responsible for organ donation within intensive care units and also that the legislation there was adjusted to include the opt-out in keeping with Spain, Belgium, Austria and Portugal. The countries that have made serious efforts on organ donation and transplants have seen major benefits, both medical and financial.. . . . I will conclude by quoting Professor Egan:
Organ donation and transplantation in Ireland is at a crossroads. With both the proposed “soft opt out” legislation and infrastructure support there is an opportunity to provide enormous benefits for generations to come. . . . ' The Motion was agreed
01 May Name The New Bridge After Tony Gregory
Click to Like & Share on Facebook
There is no one more associated with the Inner City, with the people, communities and their issues
than the late Tony Gregory.
Issues of housing, employment, street trading, drugs, crime, community, youth facilities and education.
Press Conference 12pm, Thursday 02 May 2013 - Buswell's Hotel, Molesworth Street, Dublin
26 April 2013 Housing Crisis in Dublin Central - 90% Private Flats Inspected Deemed 'Unfit' PRESS RELEASE
Click for Irish Times article
Maureen O’Sullivan TD
In response to a Department of Environment Report confirming that more than 90% of private flats inspected by Dublin City Council are unfit for habitation, Maureen O’Sullivan, Independent TD for Dublin Central states ‘I have been raising this issue regularly. It has now reached crisis point.’
‘I have constituents who regularly contact me saying they live in cramped, damp apartments; waste disposal is a huge problem.’
She continues, ‘there are also high numbers of vacant households across the area.’
‘This year marks more than 30 years since the ‘Gregory Deal’, which led to action- a construction programme of adequate social housing, training opportunities & job creation. It is shocking that we are revisiting this type of crisis again in 2013. Austerity measures have led the Government to outsource the housing issue to the private sector while simultaneously cutting rent allowance and other social supports. These circumstances are putting people at greater risk in desperate conditions.’
‘The private sector cannot and is not addressing the social needs for many of these tenants. People are experiencing poverty & unemployment. Some of them have alcohol, drug and mental health issues that require proper supports.'
‘Profit-driven landlords are not the solution, accessible adequate social housing is the solution and this requires an immediate investment of state resources.’
In response to a Department of Environment Report confirming that more than 90% of private flats inspected by Dublin City Council are unfit for habitation, Maureen O’Sullivan, Independent TD for Dublin Central states ‘I have been raising this issue regularly. It has now reached crisis point.’
‘I have constituents who regularly contact me saying they live in cramped, damp apartments; waste disposal is a huge problem.’
She continues, ‘there are also high numbers of vacant households across the area.’
‘This year marks more than 30 years since the ‘Gregory Deal’, which led to action- a construction programme of adequate social housing, training opportunities & job creation. It is shocking that we are revisiting this type of crisis again in 2013. Austerity measures have led the Government to outsource the housing issue to the private sector while simultaneously cutting rent allowance and other social supports. These circumstances are putting people at greater risk in desperate conditions.’
‘The private sector cannot and is not addressing the social needs for many of these tenants. People are experiencing poverty & unemployment. Some of them have alcohol, drug and mental health issues that require proper supports.'
‘Profit-driven landlords are not the solution, accessible adequate social housing is the solution and this requires an immediate investment of state resources.’
25 April Moore St Easter Rising 1916 Monument Site
Click to read & hear exchange on Moore Street
Maureen raised a priority question with Minister for Arts, Hertitage & Gaeltacht, J Deenihan TD about the need to take action to preserve the Moore Street Easter Rising 1916 Site.
An environmentanal impact assessment of proposed shopping mall developments is being considered by the Department.
The minister is to make a decision.
' . . . Nos. 14 to 17 are the national monument and they are only still standing by the skin of their teeth. The Minister knows that what the Save Moore Street group, the relatives and I would like is to see that area as an historic quarter. If we look at the Venice Charter and apply that to Nos. 14 to 17, Moore Street, we can see that the monument there is more than a stand-alone entity. It has to be and is linked to the surrounding environment, and part of that environment is the historic laneways and terrace of Moore Street, which is also linked with the street trading tradition that is synonymous with Dublin and with the businesses there. . . '
An environmentanal impact assessment of proposed shopping mall developments is being considered by the Department.
The minister is to make a decision.
' . . . Nos. 14 to 17 are the national monument and they are only still standing by the skin of their teeth. The Minister knows that what the Save Moore Street group, the relatives and I would like is to see that area as an historic quarter. If we look at the Venice Charter and apply that to Nos. 14 to 17, Moore Street, we can see that the monument there is more than a stand-alone entity. It has to be and is linked to the surrounding environment, and part of that environment is the historic laneways and terrace of Moore Street, which is also linked with the street trading tradition that is synonymous with Dublin and with the businesses there. . . '
25 April Maureen with Pakistani activists working with Trocaire
Short YouTube video of GRDO/Trocaire work
Meeting of members of Joint Foreign Affairs Committee at the Dáil with activists from Pakistan.
Ms Kolhi Veero who escaped from bonded labour, winner of 2009 Frederick Douglass award and an Independent candidate in forthcoming elections (provincial) in Pakistan.
Mr. Malookani Ghulam Hyder, a founder and director of Green Rural Development Origanization (GRDO) working with Trocaire to free bonded labourers on cotton farms and in factories.
23 April EU Accounting Directive Priority Question 90
Read & hear debate on Maureen's question in full
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation Richard Bruton if he recognises the importance of the EU Accounting Directive as a game changer for the entire relationship between Europe and Africa; if he will push for the best possible standards of Chapter 9 of the Directive under the Irish EU Presidency . . .
. . . This directive must mean more than that they will be better informed, because these communities are losing out big time. They should see the benefits of the resources in their countries.
Some $1 trillion disappears without trace from developing country, abetted in the main by multinational companies evading taxes. The disappearance of these moneys is also supported by corruption on the part of officials. This issue has been called the ugliest chapter in global economic affairs since slavery. . . .
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: Will Ireland build on what has been achieved in the directive, particularly in chapter 9, to create and support greater transparency in country-by-country reporting?
Deputy Richard Bruton: . . . . . As she probably knows, painstaking work is required to get these things over the line. I will convey her remarks to my officials. It is clear that abuses have developed in this area. The NGOs have been extremely exercised about it, and rightly so. The directive creates a charter for transparency.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: An effort needs to be made at UN level to highlight the issue of tax justice and to tackle the illicit movement of taxes from particular countries. Did the Government support the inclusion in the review clause of additional sectors, such as telecommunications and construction, that could be included in the directive? . . . . .
Deputy Richard Bruton: I will have to get back to the Deputy on the wider sectors she mentioned. I understand there has been broad-based support from the Council, the Parliament and the NGOs for what has been achieved here. . . . . '
. . . This directive must mean more than that they will be better informed, because these communities are losing out big time. They should see the benefits of the resources in their countries.
Some $1 trillion disappears without trace from developing country, abetted in the main by multinational companies evading taxes. The disappearance of these moneys is also supported by corruption on the part of officials. This issue has been called the ugliest chapter in global economic affairs since slavery. . . .
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: Will Ireland build on what has been achieved in the directive, particularly in chapter 9, to create and support greater transparency in country-by-country reporting?
Deputy Richard Bruton: . . . . . As she probably knows, painstaking work is required to get these things over the line. I will convey her remarks to my officials. It is clear that abuses have developed in this area. The NGOs have been extremely exercised about it, and rightly so. The directive creates a charter for transparency.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: An effort needs to be made at UN level to highlight the issue of tax justice and to tackle the illicit movement of taxes from particular countries. Did the Government support the inclusion in the review clause of additional sectors, such as telecommunications and construction, that could be included in the directive? . . . . .
Deputy Richard Bruton: I will have to get back to the Deputy on the wider sectors she mentioned. I understand there has been broad-based support from the Council, the Parliament and the NGOs for what has been achieved here. . . . . '
21 April Croke Park Stadium Catering Staff Recruitment 2013
Click for link to fitzerscatering
Fitzers Catering are recruiting for experienced part time bar and wait staff and will be holding open interviews for local residents with relevant experience for the coming season.
To apply for a position you must email the Fitzers HR department: personnel@fitzerscatering.ie
To register in advance or post an up to date CV clearly marked “Residents Application” to arrive before the 30th April 2013. (Reference Croke Park on your application).
Walk up interviews cannot be accommodated on the night.
When:Wednesday 15th May 2013 Where:Fitzers Offices, Cusack Stand, Croke Park (Entry via St Joseph’s Avenue)
Time:From 5.30pm to 7.30pm
Contact: Marti Higgins Email:personnel@fitzerscatering.ie
To apply for a position you must email the Fitzers HR department: personnel@fitzerscatering.ie
To register in advance or post an up to date CV clearly marked “Residents Application” to arrive before the 30th April 2013. (Reference Croke Park on your application).
Walk up interviews cannot be accommodated on the night.
When:Wednesday 15th May 2013 Where:Fitzers Offices, Cusack Stand, Croke Park (Entry via St Joseph’s Avenue)
Time:From 5.30pm to 7.30pm
Contact: Marti Higgins Email:personnel@fitzerscatering.ie
20 April Amendement 39 National Lottery Bill
for YouTube clip of Maureen's last amendment
17 April Amendement 39 National Lottery
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: I move amendment No. 39:
In page 25, to delete lines 36 and 37.
I may have been a little premature in moving this amendment given that legislation on mental capacity is due before the House. However, the amendment provides the Minister with an opportunity to clarify the reason a paragraph referring to mental incapacity has been included in the section. What do the terms "legal disability" and "mental incapacity" mean in this context? Is this provision singling out particular groups of people?
Deputy Brendan Howlin: I welcome the opportunity to clarify this matter. The paragraph in question is taken from the 1986 Act. Its purpose is simply to allow the national lottery to have rules on the payment of prizes to people with an intellectual disability. It does not in any way disbar or prevent people with an intellectual disability from participating in the lotto. I am a great supporter of such participation. There is also no bar or impediment to such individuals winning a prize. The provision allows the national lottery to have specific rules to ensure persons with an intellectual disability receive any prizes they may win and others cannot engage in subterfuge in this respect. The provision is to ensure that people who win get that to which they are entitled.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: I accept the Minister's clarification.
(We are attempting to further develop the website & other media to provide relevant information.
This is a first outing with YouTube. Your constructive suggestions & opinions are welcome)
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: I move amendment No. 39:
In page 25, to delete lines 36 and 37.
I may have been a little premature in moving this amendment given that legislation on mental capacity is due before the House. However, the amendment provides the Minister with an opportunity to clarify the reason a paragraph referring to mental incapacity has been included in the section. What do the terms "legal disability" and "mental incapacity" mean in this context? Is this provision singling out particular groups of people?
Deputy Brendan Howlin: I welcome the opportunity to clarify this matter. The paragraph in question is taken from the 1986 Act. Its purpose is simply to allow the national lottery to have rules on the payment of prizes to people with an intellectual disability. It does not in any way disbar or prevent people with an intellectual disability from participating in the lotto. I am a great supporter of such participation. There is also no bar or impediment to such individuals winning a prize. The provision allows the national lottery to have specific rules to ensure persons with an intellectual disability receive any prizes they may win and others cannot engage in subterfuge in this respect. The provision is to ensure that people who win get that to which they are entitled.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: I accept the Minister's clarification.
(We are attempting to further develop the website & other media to provide relevant information.
This is a first outing with YouTube. Your constructive suggestions & opinions are welcome)
18 April Tony Gregory' A name for new Liffey bridge (Irish Times letter)
Sir, – The Abbey Theatre is seeking 3,000 signatures in support of naming the new Liffey bridge “Abbey Bridge” (Frank McDonald, Home News, April 15th). The national theatre is called the Abbey because it is on Lower Abbey Street, so-called because it was the site of a medieval monastery. What would Abbey bridge commemorate, the monastery or the theatre? I am persuaded however, that the theatre does have a legitimate interest in the naming of the bridge because of its proximity.
I would prefer the bridge to be named the Tony Gregory Bridge after my late brother, who did much for the rejuvenation of Dublin’s inner city.
I can, however, see the merit in calling the bridge “Gregory bridge”. This would satisfy the theatre lobby as it would honour Augusta Gregory, co-founder of the national theatre, of whom WB Yeats wrote: “She had been to me mother, friend, sister and brother, I cannot realise the world without her, she brought to my wavering thoughts steadfast mobility”.
It would also satisfy the feminist lobby as it would be named after a woman. It would equally satisfy the Tony Gregory lobby, by commemorating him in his beloved inner city.
So why not simply call it the “Gregory Bridge” in memory of Augusta and Tony?
– Yours, etc,
NOEL GREGORY, Sackville Gardens, Ballybough, Dublin 3.
I would prefer the bridge to be named the Tony Gregory Bridge after my late brother, who did much for the rejuvenation of Dublin’s inner city.
I can, however, see the merit in calling the bridge “Gregory bridge”. This would satisfy the theatre lobby as it would honour Augusta Gregory, co-founder of the national theatre, of whom WB Yeats wrote: “She had been to me mother, friend, sister and brother, I cannot realise the world without her, she brought to my wavering thoughts steadfast mobility”.
It would also satisfy the feminist lobby as it would be named after a woman. It would equally satisfy the Tony Gregory lobby, by commemorating him in his beloved inner city.
So why not simply call it the “Gregory Bridge” in memory of Augusta and Tony?
– Yours, etc,
NOEL GREGORY, Sackville Gardens, Ballybough, Dublin 3.
18 April 'Law allowing for sale of national lottery licence passed' Irish Times
Read article in full
Amendment
During yesterday’s report stage debate on the legislation, Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform Brendan Howlin accepted an amendment from Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan to include the natural environment on the list of good causes receiving funding, which also includes the Irish language, the arts, community health, youth welfare and amenities.
Ms O’Sullivan said the Irish Environmental Network and the Irish Wildlife Trust do important work relating to the maintenance of healthy water and soils and clear air. “If we cannot do that, the current economic recession will be nothing compared to what we will face in a recession affecting the natural environment unless we look after it.”
18 April National Lottery Bill 2012: Report Stage (Amendments) to include 'natural environment'
Click to read Maureen's speech in full
Maureen was speaking on Amendment to National Lottery Bill' . . . The Irish Environmental Network and the Irish Wildlife Trust do important work and they have a wide range of programmes and activities. The thrust of what they do relates to the maintenance of healthy water and soils and clear air. If we cannot do that, the current economic recession will be nothing compared to what we will face in a recession affecting the natural environment unless we look after it. I am conscious of this because I have spent most of the past two days at a conference in Dublin Castle on hunger, nutrition and climate change where I listened to the voices of communities all over the world and the challenges facing the environment and the way of life of fishermen, farmers, pastoralists and so on. I acknowledge we are not quite in that position but we must be proactive and take our responsibility seriously. There could be an opportunity in this section to include the natural environment. I do not understand how that would open a floodgate to anything else. . . .
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: Having spent approximately five hours getting nowhere with amendments to the Animal Health and Welfare Bill, the Minister's decision to accept the amendment is welcome. I thank him and the
Deputies who spoke in favour of the amendment, from which only good can come.
. . '
17 April Statute of Limitations (Amendment) Bill 2013: Second Stage [Private Members]
Click to read Maureen's speech in full
Maureen was speaking on Private Members' Motion relationg to injustice visited on Irish women who experienced symphysiotomy. The motion was past to the next stage of Dáil debate, unanimously on 17th April
' . . . . I cannot imagine what it must have been like to have gone through it. The one word to describe the procedure is barbaric. It is very difficult to reconcile that barbarism with what we associate with the medical profession. Doctors swear the hippocratic oath, which is basically about practising medicine ethically and honestly. While there are variations of the oath, I read today a comment that warmth, sympathy and understanding may outweigh the surgeon's knife or the chemist's drug. Warmth, sympathy and understanding were very sadly lacking for the women involved. ' . . . . . . . 'I
'Historic day - honour to be part of it. Very emotional for those most affected. Another positive for equality'
After Constitutional Convention overwhelmingly supports call that the Constitution be changed to allow for civil marriages for same-sex couples.
'There was a nice irony on Sunday; some of those against same sex marriage were concerned that same sex marriage would somehow undermine or denigrate the institution of marriage - far from it - there was a very strong affirmation of the institution of marriage from same sex couples who want to be married.
After Constitutional Convention overwhelmingly supports call that the Constitution be changed to allow for civil marriages for same-sex couples.
'There was a nice irony on Sunday; some of those against same sex marriage were concerned that same sex marriage would somehow undermine or denigrate the institution of marriage - far from it - there was a very strong affirmation of the institution of marriage from same sex couples who want to be married.
14 April Constitutional Convention on Marriage Equality
Watch contributions on YouTube link
'Over 1,000 submissions to the Constitutional Convention on the subject of same sex marriage so a lot of reading last week. One struck me particularly - from U.C.C. Law school and one of the authors was at the convention today so I was able to bring it up with him. This was to do with the fact that our Constitution, including the Preamble, are very much based on the principle of equality, respect for the dignity and freedom of each individual and that articles 41 and 42 did not preclude marriage rights for same sex couples. My question was why then has it been interpreted as meaning man and woman. His answer was that it was politicians who do that. His view as a constitutional lawyer was that marriage between same sex couples was allowed by our constitution.
The submissions on both sides were very interesting and all delivered in a spirit of dignity and respect; as were all the comments and questions from the floor.
At times I found it emotional, particularly when the gay participants spoke very movingly of their own situation, being denied a right that heterosexual people have. Back this Sunday morning for the vote.'
11th April Local Property Tax . .wrong time to be introducing it when the country is in the middle of a recession . . .'
I would have preferred to have seen the government look more seriously at a 'site valuation tax', as proposed by a number of groups like Social Justice Ireland. This would have see derelict sites being taxed and I think would have been fairer overall.
However, I do agree in principle with a Property Tax, that is fair and equitable and based on ability to pay. And where the revenue raised goes towards badly needed local services and does not go to pay bank debt or bondholders.
But this is the wrong time to be introducing a Property Tax when the country is in the middle of a recession. Also there are not enough exemptions and options for deferring for those who are unable to pay.
There is a significant issue in parts of Dublin Central for those homes that have been flooded, many on more than one occasion. They cannot get insurance against flood, therefore the value of their houses is considerably less than similar houses in areas which have not been flooded.
I will pay the tax. I am able to pay it and if still teaching I would also be able to pay it.
Consideration has to be given to those who are unable to pay.
However, I do agree in principle with a Property Tax, that is fair and equitable and based on ability to pay. And where the revenue raised goes towards badly needed local services and does not go to pay bank debt or bondholders.
But this is the wrong time to be introducing a Property Tax when the country is in the middle of a recession. Also there are not enough exemptions and options for deferring for those who are unable to pay.
There is a significant issue in parts of Dublin Central for those homes that have been flooded, many on more than one occasion. They cannot get insurance against flood, therefore the value of their houses is considerably less than similar houses in areas which have not been flooded.
I will pay the tax. I am able to pay it and if still teaching I would also be able to pay it.
Consideration has to be given to those who are unable to pay.
30 March Alternative Energy Projects Priority Question 3
Click to read & hear debate in full
Foreign Affairs Priority Question asked on 28th March
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade his views on the European Commission's proposal to limit the use of crop based biofuels in transport by 2020 to 5%; if he will include this issue on the agenda of the upcoming Hunger Summit; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (Deputy Joe Costello): ' . . . . . . . Following a number of studies, in October 2012 the Commission published a proposal to amend the Renewable Energy Directive and the Fuel Quality Directive. The Commission included a proposal that the 10% quota be reduced to 5%.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: It is rather ironic that the renewable energy directive, which has the grand ideal of working to combat climate change, should have such a negative effect. There is no doubt that the bio-fuel industry is driving land-grabbing in Africa. Some of the scientific data and reports we have received bear this out. Recently an NGO from Kenya told us about the circumstances in that country. It is reckoned that 40 million hectares have been taken from African land for bio-fuels since 2000, and this is having very negative effects, such as land displacement and evictions. These, in turn, cause hunger and water shortages. I will not address the labour issues associated with some of the companies involved.
Is Ireland supporting the reduction of the cap to 5%? When the Tánaiste addresses the Mary Robinson Foundation's conference, will he be saying that Ireland will support the 5% cap?
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade his views on the European Commission's proposal to limit the use of crop based biofuels in transport by 2020 to 5%; if he will include this issue on the agenda of the upcoming Hunger Summit; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Minister of State at the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (Deputy Joe Costello): ' . . . . . . . Following a number of studies, in October 2012 the Commission published a proposal to amend the Renewable Energy Directive and the Fuel Quality Directive. The Commission included a proposal that the 10% quota be reduced to 5%.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: It is rather ironic that the renewable energy directive, which has the grand ideal of working to combat climate change, should have such a negative effect. There is no doubt that the bio-fuel industry is driving land-grabbing in Africa. Some of the scientific data and reports we have received bear this out. Recently an NGO from Kenya told us about the circumstances in that country. It is reckoned that 40 million hectares have been taken from African land for bio-fuels since 2000, and this is having very negative effects, such as land displacement and evictions. These, in turn, cause hunger and water shortages. I will not address the labour issues associated with some of the companies involved.
Is Ireland supporting the reduction of the cap to 5%? When the Tánaiste addresses the Mary Robinson Foundation's conference, will he be saying that Ireland will support the 5% cap?
27 March Animal Welfare Bill Amendment Ban on Hare Coursing
Click to read amendment debate
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: I am appalled that in the previous vote only 14 of the 120 Members in this Chamber today voted in favour of banning fur farming. When it became known in animal welfare circles that the Minister was working on this Bill, there was a great sense that finally we were going to do the right thing and that cruel practices such as hare coursing, the gassing of mink and the culling of badgers would finally be eradicated.
I want to go back to the beginning of the Bill. In the Long Title, on page seven, it is definitely stated that the aim of the Bill is to prevent cruelty to animals. Under Part 3, which is entitled "Animal Welfare", on page 13, it is stated that a person who is in possession of a protected animal must ensure that the animal is treated in a manner that safeguards the health and welfare of the animal and does not threaten the health or welfare of the animal or another animal. Nobody can tell me that coursing is the sort of activity in which the welfare of the animal is not at stake and in which there is no cruelty.
I refer to an interesting quotation from a German philosopher, Immanuel Kant: "He who is cruel to animals becomes hard also in his dealings with men. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals." Irish men are not coming across very well when we see the way in which animals are being treated in this country. I do not think it is doing our international reputation any good to be one of three countries that continue to allow live coursing. I understand that The Gathering has also removed hunting from its website. This was a golden opportunity to get rid of hare coursing. It is obvious that the majority of people in this country totally oppose it. I know that Deputies are annoyed by the volume of e-mails they receive on this matter, but this shows the extent of the support for putting a ban on coursing.
I want to go back to the beginning of the Bill. In the Long Title, on page seven, it is definitely stated that the aim of the Bill is to prevent cruelty to animals. Under Part 3, which is entitled "Animal Welfare", on page 13, it is stated that a person who is in possession of a protected animal must ensure that the animal is treated in a manner that safeguards the health and welfare of the animal and does not threaten the health or welfare of the animal or another animal. Nobody can tell me that coursing is the sort of activity in which the welfare of the animal is not at stake and in which there is no cruelty.
I refer to an interesting quotation from a German philosopher, Immanuel Kant: "He who is cruel to animals becomes hard also in his dealings with men. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals." Irish men are not coming across very well when we see the way in which animals are being treated in this country. I do not think it is doing our international reputation any good to be one of three countries that continue to allow live coursing. I understand that The Gathering has also removed hunting from its website. This was a golden opportunity to get rid of hare coursing. It is obvious that the majority of people in this country totally oppose it. I know that Deputies are annoyed by the volume of e-mails they receive on this matter, but this shows the extent of the support for putting a ban on coursing.
27 March Animal Health & Welfare Bill Amendment on Ban on Fur Farming
Click to read full amendment debate
Maureen was speaking on the first of a number of her amendments on the Bill,
" . . . . . We also see a phasing out of fur farming in other countries and that would have a been a sensible approach to take here.
I also discussed before the way animals are gassed. The second part of my amendment relates to the welfare of the mink. The Minister says he wants greater regulation, so fur farming will not be banned in this Bill. Therefore, there is a need for much stronger controls over how the mink are held and how they are gassed. As I pointed out on Committee Stage, there are serious issues for the environment. Fur has a higher impact in respect of 17 of the 18 environmental themes, including climate change and toxic emissions. The climate change impact of 1 kg of mink fur is five times greater than that of the highest scoring textile wool, owing to the feeding requirements and the nitrous oxide emissions from mink manure.
There are two issues in question here. I would love to see fur farming banned and do not understand why we must retain it in this day and age. We could follow the good example of other countries in Europe and even if we do not ban it outright, consider phasing it out. In the meantime, we must show more concern for the welfare of the mink while they are being kept in captivity and about the way they are gassed. There is also an issue with regard to mink escaping from captivity and damaging bird life in their area. . . . "
" . . . . . We also see a phasing out of fur farming in other countries and that would have a been a sensible approach to take here.
I also discussed before the way animals are gassed. The second part of my amendment relates to the welfare of the mink. The Minister says he wants greater regulation, so fur farming will not be banned in this Bill. Therefore, there is a need for much stronger controls over how the mink are held and how they are gassed. As I pointed out on Committee Stage, there are serious issues for the environment. Fur has a higher impact in respect of 17 of the 18 environmental themes, including climate change and toxic emissions. The climate change impact of 1 kg of mink fur is five times greater than that of the highest scoring textile wool, owing to the feeding requirements and the nitrous oxide emissions from mink manure.
There are two issues in question here. I would love to see fur farming banned and do not understand why we must retain it in this day and age. We could follow the good example of other countries in Europe and even if we do not ban it outright, consider phasing it out. In the meantime, we must show more concern for the welfare of the mink while they are being kept in captivity and about the way they are gassed. There is also an issue with regard to mink escaping from captivity and damaging bird life in their area. . . . "
21 March Abuse of human rights of the Rohingya people in Burma - Dáil Parliamentary Question
Attacks on Rohingya 21 March 2013
Parliamentary Question - Dept Details
To ask the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he will engage further with the authorities in Burma on the abuse of human rights of the Rohingya people who are deprived of basic civil entitlements like the right to education, land ownership and so on, now facing the triple threat of disease, starvation and violence; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
- Maureen O'Sullivan TD
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 20th March, 2013.
REPLY
The Government continues to closely monitor reports of human rights abuses of the Rohingya people in Burma/Myanmar and is concerned about the situation.
While Ireland’s diplomatic relations with Burma/Myanmar are maintained on a secondary accreditation basis via our Embassy in Vietnam, and through the Embassy of Burma/Myanmar in London, we continue also to work through the mechanisms of the EU and UN to ensure that human rights are respected in Burma/Myanmar, including those of the Rohingya people.
On 28 January 2013, the Irish Ambassador in Hanoi presented his credentials to become the first Ambassador of Ireland accredited to Burma/Myanmar. Following accreditation, the Ambassador met with both the President and Foreign Minister of Burma/Myanmar and discussed a range of issues, including the human rights situation in Rakhine State.
As an elected member of the Human Rights Council, Ireland is working closely with partners at the Council to ensure the continuation of international scrutiny of the human rights situation in Burma/Myanmar.
At the 67th session of the United Nations General Assembly Ireland along with our international partners urged the Government of Burma/Myanmar to accelerate its efforts to address human rights concerns and called upon the Government there to grant safe, timely, full and unhindered access across Rakhine State.
President Thein Sein visited Brussels on 5 March. He met with High Representative Catherine Ashton as well as with President of the Commission José Manuel Barroso and President of the European Council Herman Van Rompuy. Following this latter meeting, a Joint Statement was released in which both sides agreed to work in partnership to promote human rights and the rule of law for all people living in Burma/Myanmar, including the Rohingya.
Ireland’s recent experience in development cooperation in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia as well as in Timor Leste is relevant to Burma/Myanmar, and we stand ready to share this experience to assist in its development and democratisation. To date, Irish Aid has provided over €7m to Burma / Myanmar through NGOs and Irish missionaries for long term development and emergency and recovery responses.
Ireland will continue to urge the Government of Burma/Myanmar, both bilaterally and through the relevant multilateral channels, to address the human rights situation of the Rohingya.
ENDS
To ask the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he will engage further with the authorities in Burma on the abuse of human rights of the Rohingya people who are deprived of basic civil entitlements like the right to education, land ownership and so on, now facing the triple threat of disease, starvation and violence; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
- Maureen O'Sullivan TD
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 20th March, 2013.
REPLY
The Government continues to closely monitor reports of human rights abuses of the Rohingya people in Burma/Myanmar and is concerned about the situation.
While Ireland’s diplomatic relations with Burma/Myanmar are maintained on a secondary accreditation basis via our Embassy in Vietnam, and through the Embassy of Burma/Myanmar in London, we continue also to work through the mechanisms of the EU and UN to ensure that human rights are respected in Burma/Myanmar, including those of the Rohingya people.
On 28 January 2013, the Irish Ambassador in Hanoi presented his credentials to become the first Ambassador of Ireland accredited to Burma/Myanmar. Following accreditation, the Ambassador met with both the President and Foreign Minister of Burma/Myanmar and discussed a range of issues, including the human rights situation in Rakhine State.
As an elected member of the Human Rights Council, Ireland is working closely with partners at the Council to ensure the continuation of international scrutiny of the human rights situation in Burma/Myanmar.
At the 67th session of the United Nations General Assembly Ireland along with our international partners urged the Government of Burma/Myanmar to accelerate its efforts to address human rights concerns and called upon the Government there to grant safe, timely, full and unhindered access across Rakhine State.
President Thein Sein visited Brussels on 5 March. He met with High Representative Catherine Ashton as well as with President of the Commission José Manuel Barroso and President of the European Council Herman Van Rompuy. Following this latter meeting, a Joint Statement was released in which both sides agreed to work in partnership to promote human rights and the rule of law for all people living in Burma/Myanmar, including the Rohingya.
Ireland’s recent experience in development cooperation in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia as well as in Timor Leste is relevant to Burma/Myanmar, and we stand ready to share this experience to assist in its development and democratisation. To date, Irish Aid has provided over €7m to Burma / Myanmar through NGOs and Irish missionaries for long term development and emergency and recovery responses.
Ireland will continue to urge the Government of Burma/Myanmar, both bilaterally and through the relevant multilateral channels, to address the human rights situation of the Rohingya.
ENDS
21 March Disablility Supports Motion
Click to read Maureen's full speech
Maureen was speaking on the disability Supports Motion. " Ba mhaith liom comhghairdeas a dhéanamh leis an Teachta Finian McGrath agus gabhaim buíochas leis ar son an obair a dhein sé i gcóir an Gnó Príomháideach seo. Aithníom, chomh maith, an obair a dhein sé thar na blianta ar son lucht míchumais. Credit is due to Deputy Finian McGrath for this Private Members' motion. There is a need for recognition of him as being a voice for those with disabilities, both in his time on Dublin City Council and also in the Dáil.
One of the most shameful moments that I experienced in my few years here was some months ago when persons with disabilities, in their wheelchairs, including some past pupils of mine from St. Mary's Baldoyle, took part in a protest outside the Dáil. It was an overnight protest to highlight their situation and the implications of the threatened cuts. I must ask what kind of society are we that any consideration or any thought would go to making life more difficult for those with disabilities. We know we are living in challenging times but those challenges are really compounded for those with disabilities. They have so many additional challenges and those challenges extend to their families and their loved ones. . . . . "
One of the most shameful moments that I experienced in my few years here was some months ago when persons with disabilities, in their wheelchairs, including some past pupils of mine from St. Mary's Baldoyle, took part in a protest outside the Dáil. It was an overnight protest to highlight their situation and the implications of the threatened cuts. I must ask what kind of society are we that any consideration or any thought would go to making life more difficult for those with disabilities. We know we are living in challenging times but those challenges are really compounded for those with disabilities. They have so many additional challenges and those challenges extend to their families and their loved ones. . . . . "
12 March Criminal Justice (Spent Convictions) Bill 2012
Click to read Maureen's speech in full
Maureen speaking on Spent convictions Bill, 'The Criminal Justice (Spent Convictions) Bill 2012 provides that, subject to certain conditions, somebody who has been convicted of a minor offence will not be required to disclose it when applying for a job. There is a great line at the end of "Macbeth" when Macbeth considers the wrong he has done and says:
I am in blood
Stepp'd in so far that, should I wade no more,
Returning were as tedious as go o'er:
In other words, it was easier to continue committing crimes than to start over. There is something wrong if it is easier to continue in crime than to start a new life. If we are serious about reducing the level of recidivism and stopping the revolving door, we have to act. . . . . . '
I am in blood
Stepp'd in so far that, should I wade no more,
Returning were as tedious as go o'er:
In other words, it was easier to continue committing crimes than to start over. There is something wrong if it is easier to continue in crime than to start a new life. If we are serious about reducing the level of recidivism and stopping the revolving door, we have to act. . . . . . '
10 March Dáil Question on Child Benefit
Link to 'Mangan' report on Child & Family Support
Question No: 117 Ref No: 12088-13
To the Minister for Social Protection
To ask the Minister for Social Protection the number of families that have voluntarily given up their child benefit payment either for financial or other reasons. - Maureen O'Sullivan.
For WRITTEN answer on Thursday, 7th March, 2013.
R E P L Y
Minister for Social Protection (Joan Burton T.D):
The Department is only aware of two families that have voluntarily given up entitlement to child benefit by way of submitting a clear request that payment be discontinued.
However, it may be possible that others have chosen not to respond to correspondence and have, by default, discontinued claiming child benefit.
To the Minister for Social Protection
To ask the Minister for Social Protection the number of families that have voluntarily given up their child benefit payment either for financial or other reasons. - Maureen O'Sullivan.
For WRITTEN answer on Thursday, 7th March, 2013.
R E P L Y
Minister for Social Protection (Joan Burton T.D):
The Department is only aware of two families that have voluntarily given up entitlement to child benefit by way of submitting a clear request that payment be discontinued.
However, it may be possible that others have chosen not to respond to correspondence and have, by default, discontinued claiming child benefit.
08 March Autism Bill 2012: Second Stage Private Members
Click to read Maureen's full statement
Maureen speaking on Autism Bill, 'Ba mhaith liom aitheantas a thabhairt don Teachta McCarthy de réir na hoibre atá déanta aige ar an mBille an-tábhachtach agus riachtanach seo.
The words "Autism is not me. Autism is just an information processing problem that controls who I am" is a quotation from the author of the books entitled, rather interestingly, Nobody, Nowhere and Somebody, Somewhere.
Generally, we are talking about those sharing a triad of impairments that affects their ability to understand and use non-verbal and verbal communication and understand social behaviour, and their ability to interact with others. They show restricted obsessional or repetitive activities, and there is the additional dimension relating to the difficulties in processing sensory information. . . .'
The words "Autism is not me. Autism is just an information processing problem that controls who I am" is a quotation from the author of the books entitled, rather interestingly, Nobody, Nowhere and Somebody, Somewhere.
Generally, we are talking about those sharing a triad of impairments that affects their ability to understand and use non-verbal and verbal communication and understand social behaviour, and their ability to interact with others. They show restricted obsessional or repetitive activities, and there is the additional dimension relating to the difficulties in processing sensory information. . . .'
08 March International Women's Day
Click to link to other events
LET’S WALK & TALK, BIMÍS AG SIÚL AGUS AG CAINT
International Women’s Day will be celebrated at 11am on Friday with Dublin City Council’s Irish language walking group as they visit Leinster House where they will meet with Independent Dublin Central TD Maureen O’Sullivan and receiving a tour of the Houses of the Oireachtas.
International Women’s Day will be celebrated at 11am on Friday with Dublin City Council’s Irish language walking group as they visit Leinster House where they will meet with Independent Dublin Central TD Maureen O’Sullivan and receiving a tour of the Houses of the Oireachtas.
06 March Topical Issue Mental Health Services
Funding for community residential mental health services since implementation of A Vision for Change
Click to read Topical Issue debate in full
There is a need for a system that would track the activities of community-based mental health services and funding. I draw the attention of the House to the report, published on 1 February, of the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, Mr. Juan Mendez, which looks at abuses in health care settings that may cross the threshold of mistreatment and be a form of torture or cruel and degrading treatment. In looking at mental health legislation within the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, Mr. Mendez established that community living with support is no longer a favourable policy development but an internationally recognised right.
Community mental health services are not an established right in Ireland. While this was first proposed in 1984 and again in A Vision for Change in 2006, we are still awaiting the move from residential and institutional care to community care. While the policy in this regard has been in place for more than 30 years, it has not been the practice. I support the call by Amnesty International for legislation in this area to provide that health authorities are duty-bound to account for and ultimately deliver community mental health services.
Community mental health services are not an established right in Ireland. While this was first proposed in 1984 and again in A Vision for Change in 2006, we are still awaiting the move from residential and institutional care to community care. While the policy in this regard has been in place for more than 30 years, it has not been the practice. I support the call by Amnesty International for legislation in this area to provide that health authorities are duty-bound to account for and ultimately deliver community mental health services.
26 February State Forestry Motion
Click to read Maureen's full speech
Maureen speaking on Technnical Group Motion on Coillte asset sale," . . . . The first question we must ask is whether the sale of the harvesting rights would make sense economically or financially, or from the perspective of our heritage and culture. We need to highlight the need to stress-test the implications of the full or partial sale of harvesting rights for the future commercial viability of the sector, including the sawmill sector. Like other Deputies, I have read Dr. Peter Bacon's report assessing the consequences of the proposed sale. I went to the Oireachtas audio-visual room today to hear some of the comments he had to make. His report makes some very logical arguments against the sell-off of harvesting rights, purely for economic reasons. He suggests this measure would cost the State money, rather than generating income for it. He provides some interesting statistics in support of his position: the loss of funds from Coillte's profit flow would cost the State €565 million; in addition, the company's deficit funding requirement is €313 million, its debt liability is €172 million, while its pension liability is €130 million. The economic cost of the job losses or the loss of the amenity value must also be considered. . . . . "
25 February 'Way we treat asylum seekers will be State's next apology' Irish Times
Read Irish Times article in full
" . . . Last week in the Dáil, on the same day that the Taoiseach apologised to the Magdalene women, a written question revealed that the Irish taxpayer paid out €655 million between 2000 and 2010 to provide asylum seekers with accommodation. That is a very high price to pay for the luxury of forgetting about a group of people you don’t like.
That same accommodation was characterised by a European Commission on Human Rights report last December as having “negative consequences on their mental health, family ties and integration prospects”.
“The response has been muted,” said Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan, who tabled the written question. . . . "
24 February Table Quiz
Click for info on Alrowad Centre
In aid of the community cultural centre
Alrowwad,
Palestine
Thurs 28th Feb 8.30pm
Cleary's, Amiens St,
Dublin
Get your team along!
23 February TDs call for forum to openly record testimonies of laundry survivors
Click for irish Examiner article
'Independent TD Maureen O’Sullivan, who has campaigned for former residents, said the placement of women in the laundries had breached the Constitution.
She said she supported calls for an archive for survivors’ testimonies and hoped the issue of compensation would not be delayed. '
21 February Human Rights Issues Priority Question Foreign Affairs & Trade
Click to read reply to Maureen's question in full
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he has made representations to the British authorities on the location of the Royal Pardon which had been granted to Marian and the late Dolours Price; his views on whether the granting of the Pardon is being disregarded and Marian Price continues to be detained in prison and is in very poor health. [9030/13]
Deputy Eamon Gilmore: Genuine concerns have repeatedly been raised about several aspects of this case by Deputies in the House and I have raised concerns very frankly with the British Government over the past two years, most recently when I met the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland Monday, 11 February. The individual in question was sentenced in 1973 to two life terms and 20 years imprisonment to run concurrently on charges arising from the bombing of the Old Bailey. She was released in 1980 and has been detained since 13 May 2011 following the revocation of her life licence by the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. . . .
. . . . . Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: Can the Tánaiste request that one of the officials from the Northern Ireland Office attend the review?
Deputy Eamon Gilmore: The Deputy can be assured that our officials will monitor the issue very closely.
Deputy Eamon Gilmore: Genuine concerns have repeatedly been raised about several aspects of this case by Deputies in the House and I have raised concerns very frankly with the British Government over the past two years, most recently when I met the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland Monday, 11 February. The individual in question was sentenced in 1973 to two life terms and 20 years imprisonment to run concurrently on charges arising from the bombing of the Old Bailey. She was released in 1980 and has been detained since 13 May 2011 following the revocation of her life licence by the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. . . .
. . . . . Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: Can the Tánaiste request that one of the officials from the Northern Ireland Office attend the review?
Deputy Eamon Gilmore: The Deputy can be assured that our officials will monitor the issue very closely.
20 February Asylum Seeker Accommodation Dáil Question
Click for full reply to question
Written Answers 267. Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Minister for Justice and Equality Information Alan Shatter the value of the individual contracts to providers of direct provision accommodation; and if these contracts were advertised and awarded as per the EU public procurement regulations.
Minister for Justice and Equality (Deputy Alan Shatter): The question relates to the spending and procurement policy of the Reception and Integration Agency (RIA), a functional unit of the Irish Naturalisation and Immigration Service (INIS) of my Department, which is responsible for the accommodation of persons while their applications for international protection are being processed. Currently there are 4,836 persons accommodated throughout the State in 35 centres under contract to RIA.
Of the 35 centres in the State, 7 are State owned. That is to say, while the centres are managed by private contractors under contract to RIA, the land and buildings are owned by the State. Details of all centres currently under contract to RIA are available on its website - www.ria.gov.ie
Minister for Justice and Equality (Deputy Alan Shatter): The question relates to the spending and procurement policy of the Reception and Integration Agency (RIA), a functional unit of the Irish Naturalisation and Immigration Service (INIS) of my Department, which is responsible for the accommodation of persons while their applications for international protection are being processed. Currently there are 4,836 persons accommodated throughout the State in 35 centres under contract to RIA.
Of the 35 centres in the State, 7 are State owned. That is to say, while the centres are managed by private contractors under contract to RIA, the land and buildings are owned by the State. Details of all centres currently under contract to RIA are available on its website - www.ria.gov.ie
20 February Mortgage Restructuring Private Members' Motion
Click to read Maureen's speech in full
The experience of losing one's home must be added to those most stressful experiences in a person's life. I acknowledge the Government inherited a severe mortgage arrears crisis and that its amendment outlines the steps taken to address it, including the mortgage-to-rent scheme, the Personal Insolvency Act and the engagement by banks in mortgage advice. However, the point is that if all these measures were working, people and society would be seeing the benefits and one would be able to discern a decrease both in the number of mortgage holders in distress and in those at risk of distress. Instead however, we are seeing the severe impact of the mortgage debt crisis. At the end of 2010, statistics indicated that one in ten residential mortgages were in trouble. A few months later the figure was one in nine mortgages, then one in eight and this evening's Sinn Féin motion states the figure is one in four. Consequently, it is obvious that the measures are not sufficient.
Moreover, one week ago Professor Honohan stated, "I fully agree that not enough has been achieved on the mortgage arrears". He was expressing his frustration, and that of the Central Bank, that the performance of the banks is not good enough. He spoke of the dilemma that were the Central Bank to issue a directive to the banks, it would give the latter an out and they could then absolve themselves of all responsibility. However, responsibility does lie with the individual banks which gave the mortgages.
Moreover, one week ago Professor Honohan stated, "I fully agree that not enough has been achieved on the mortgage arrears". He was expressing his frustration, and that of the Central Bank, that the performance of the banks is not good enough. He spoke of the dilemma that were the Central Bank to issue a directive to the banks, it would give the latter an out and they could then absolve themselves of all responsibility. However, responsibility does lie with the individual banks which gave the mortgages.
19 February Dáil Statements on Magdalene Laundries report
Link for Justice For Magdalenes response
It was a very moving few hours in the Dáil this evening when the Taoiseach spoke. The most important reaction was that from the ladies of the Magdalene Laundries who were in the gallery and it was obvious they were relieved, gladdened and very receptive of what the Taoiseach said.
The apology was heartfelt and both his and the speech from the Minister for Justice set out the process of redress, reparation and justice; the apology was the first step; there will be a fitting memorial, as decided by the ladies, redress will occur and there will be no adversarial process.
We must never forget this very dark time in our history. The ladies need not feel any shame or stigma; the shame and the stigma are for the State and society who allowed his horror continue for so long.
19 February Maureen O'Sullivan's Statement on the Magdalene Laundries Report
Click to read Maureen's full statement
"I remember attending a play written by Louise Lowe which was set in the laundry on Sean MacDermott Street. Three audience members were brought in at a time. We were brought through the various stages by the people playing the parts of the ladies. In character, one of them said, "Will you tell?". I reacted and asked, "Who will I tell?"
I was only thinking about it afterwards and I thought, who would I have told if I was aware of what was going on? The State, church, Garda and Judiciary were involved, as well as so many other departments in society and families also, so there was nobody to tell.
I was struck by that because the Constitutional Convention is examining the Constitution. When I spoke on behalf of the Independent Members at the opening of that convention, I said that the Constitution defines who we are and how we want to be identified. A number of us expressed our disappointment that initially there was not more in the convention on economic, social and cultural rights. . . . "
I was only thinking about it afterwards and I thought, who would I have told if I was aware of what was going on? The State, church, Garda and Judiciary were involved, as well as so many other departments in society and families also, so there was nobody to tell.
I was struck by that because the Constitutional Convention is examining the Constitution. When I spoke on behalf of the Independent Members at the opening of that convention, I said that the Constitution defines who we are and how we want to be identified. A number of us expressed our disappointment that initially there was not more in the convention on economic, social and cultural rights. . . . "
15 February Mental Health Services Priority Question
Click to read debate in full
Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Minister for Health Information on Dr. James Reilly Zoom on Dr. James Reilly if he will provide a breakdown in relation to the 477 posts allocated for mental health in the Health Service Executive's 2013 National Service Plan; the number of staff of each discipline that will be appointed; to which service, old age, intellectual disability, forensics and so on; to which geographical areas they will be allocated; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Deputy James Reilly:The 2006 report of the expert group on mental health policy on the implementation of A Vision for Change is a priority for the Government. In this regard, budget 2012 and budget 2013 provided an additional €35 million each year for the continued development of our mental health services. The Health Service Executive, HSE, national service plan 2013 commits to a number of objectives including the further development of forensics and community mental health teams for adults, children, older persons and mental health intellectual disability and to the recruitment of 477 additional staff to implement these measures.
Deputy James Reilly:The 2006 report of the expert group on mental health policy on the implementation of A Vision for Change is a priority for the Government. In this regard, budget 2012 and budget 2013 provided an additional €35 million each year for the continued development of our mental health services. The Health Service Executive, HSE, national service plan 2013 commits to a number of objectives including the further development of forensics and community mental health teams for adults, children, older persons and mental health intellectual disability and to the recruitment of 477 additional staff to implement these measures.
14 February Promissory Notes Motion
Click to read Maureen's speech in full
Maureen speaking on Promissory Notes Motion, "Bhí mé i mo shuí anseo an tseachtain seo caite ag éisteacht leis an Taoiseach agus ina dhiaidh sin leis an Aire. Bhí mé ag súil go mbeadh rud iontach ag teachta a bheadh dearfach don tír seo. I was in the House last week and wanted to share in the good news and take part in the applause. I also wanted to believe it was good news. I come to this debate without a background in or studying economics. Therefore, I look at the newspapers. Certainly, the views of the economists appear to have been favourable because the headlines suggested the deal would cut borrowing by €20 billion and ease the next budget; that it was a considerable achievement for the coalition parties; that it was a highly important political achievement; that the deal would be worth €8 billion to the State; and that austerity in the coming years would be less harsh owing to the debt deal. In fact, the bond markets reacted positively. The views expressed in the national newspapers appeared to be favourable, while the international media appeared to be of the same opinion. The New York Times stated it was another important milestone in our slow emergence from the crisis. A German newspaper saw the deal as Ireland winning the argument and suggested it was of financial and symbolic importance to it. . . . "
13th February Magdalene Laundries: Motion
Click to read Maureen's comments in full
Maureen was speaking on Motion on Magdelene Laundries report'
" . . . Regardless of the controversy over the report, it found that there was State involvement and forced and unpaid labour. The women worked for State agencies and abuse occurred. The UN Committee against Torture previously produced a critical report on these matters. We need to start with a meaningful apology and move on to a transparent and non-adversarial compensation process to deal with pensions, health, housing and other issues arising for the women to ensure their needs are not lost in a complicated legal process. A dedicated unit is required to be established within the Department of Justice and Equality to work with the ladies and their support groups. . . "
06 Feb Magdalene Laundries Priority Question
Click to read the priority question on report
Maureen, asked a Priority Question with respect to the McAleese report on Magdelene Laundries:
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Minister for Justice and Equality Alan Shatter if, in progressing the issues relating to the Magdalen laundries, he is considering an apology and a redress and restorative justice scheme and if he will establish a dedicated helpline and outreach service to provide much needed assistance for the ladies of the laundries.
Deputy Alan Shatter: I announced yesterday the publication of the final report of the interdepartmental committee, independently chaired by former Senator, Dr. Martin McAleese, to establish the facts of State involvement with the Magdalen laundries. The report is extensive and detailed and, as has been stated in the House yesterday and today, runs to over 1,100 pages spanning the decades from 1922 onwards. . . .
. . . . Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: It is interesting to note the first parliamentary question about the Magdalen laundries was asked in 1938. It has taken quite a while to get from 1938 to 2013, when we now know the facts and everything that has been established. The committee hopes the report "will be a real step in bringing healing and peace of mind to all concerned, most especially the women whose lived experience of the Magdalen Laundries had a profound and enduring negative effect on their lives". On the radio this morning Felice Gaer from the UN Committee against Torture stated the State must ensure the women obtain redress and have an enforceable right to compensation. The report is complex and the best tribute to it is to start acting on what has been found. There is no doubt there was State complicity. Will the Minister offer a dedicated unit in the Department to work with Justice for Magdalenes to address these issues and look for what the ladies have been looking for, starting with an apology? . . .
. . . Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: It is very difficult to accept what the Minister said with regard to this being the first comprehensive report. Perhaps it is, but on what basis then did the Minister make his comments when he was in opposition about barbaric cruelty and women being treated appallingly and irrefutable evidence of State complicity?
I will now refer to the apology. In 1999, there was an apology to the survivors of industrial schools before the inquiry or the redress scheme. There was a further apology in 2009. Why is it so hard to apologise now, not just on behalf of the Government but also on behalf of the citizens of this State? We are all complicit in this.
Will the Minister at least give a commitment to work with the unit in his Department? I do not know what a two-day debate will achieve. We will have more rhetoric and political footballs. It is much more important to work with the survivors and their groups to address the issues, rather than talking about it for another two days in here.
Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan asked the Minister for Justice and Equality Alan Shatter if, in progressing the issues relating to the Magdalen laundries, he is considering an apology and a redress and restorative justice scheme and if he will establish a dedicated helpline and outreach service to provide much needed assistance for the ladies of the laundries.
Deputy Alan Shatter: I announced yesterday the publication of the final report of the interdepartmental committee, independently chaired by former Senator, Dr. Martin McAleese, to establish the facts of State involvement with the Magdalen laundries. The report is extensive and detailed and, as has been stated in the House yesterday and today, runs to over 1,100 pages spanning the decades from 1922 onwards. . . .
. . . . Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: It is interesting to note the first parliamentary question about the Magdalen laundries was asked in 1938. It has taken quite a while to get from 1938 to 2013, when we now know the facts and everything that has been established. The committee hopes the report "will be a real step in bringing healing and peace of mind to all concerned, most especially the women whose lived experience of the Magdalen Laundries had a profound and enduring negative effect on their lives". On the radio this morning Felice Gaer from the UN Committee against Torture stated the State must ensure the women obtain redress and have an enforceable right to compensation. The report is complex and the best tribute to it is to start acting on what has been found. There is no doubt there was State complicity. Will the Minister offer a dedicated unit in the Department to work with Justice for Magdalenes to address these issues and look for what the ladies have been looking for, starting with an apology? . . .
. . . Deputy Maureen O'Sullivan: It is very difficult to accept what the Minister said with regard to this being the first comprehensive report. Perhaps it is, but on what basis then did the Minister make his comments when he was in opposition about barbaric cruelty and women being treated appallingly and irrefutable evidence of State complicity?
I will now refer to the apology. In 1999, there was an apology to the survivors of industrial schools before the inquiry or the redress scheme. There was a further apology in 2009. Why is it so hard to apologise now, not just on behalf of the Government but also on behalf of the citizens of this State? We are all complicit in this.
Will the Minister at least give a commitment to work with the unit in his Department? I do not know what a two-day debate will achieve. We will have more rhetoric and political footballs. It is much more important to work with the survivors and their groups to address the issues, rather than talking about it for another two days in here.
06 Feb Promissory Notes: Dáil Technical Group Motion
Click to read Maureen's speech in full
Maureen speaking on Dáil Technical Group Motion,
" . . . . I want to live in an Ireland of rights and responsibilities. My first question, therefore, is, how is it the responsibility of the Irish nation to pay €3.1 billion for Anglo Irish Bank promissory notes? Second, what right has the Government to take this on when it is obvious it is unfair? Third, is it fair that Irish people should pay for something in which they had no hand, act or part?
We are repeatedly and relentlessly told that the promissory notes scheme is the only means by which Ireland can get back on its own two feet and the backbone of the State, namely, the banks, can be saved. I believe the people are the backbone of this State and they should not be sacrificed for the greed, recklessness and self interest of others. More than enough has been asked of people. Asking the same people to pay more is, in my view, arrogant. Where is there a moral obligation on the State to pay this? Surely the moral obligation is to address the needs of the people. Where is the sense of moral obligation on the part of those individuals from the various banks and organisations, who are household names, to accept responsibility for what they have done? I would like to know if they are in any sense paying for what they have done and the mess they have created. They appear to have lost considerable wealth yet exist on incredible levels of income and resources. Many other people are making sacrifices and losing so much in terms of jobs and houses. We know the effects of this on people's mental and emotional health and how all of this contributes to their sense of powerlessness. . .
. . . . There is a carcass of a building in Dublin Central which was supposed to have been the headquarters of the new Anglo Irish Bank. Some people believe should it remain as a reminder of what can and does go wrong. It is interesting that the community which took on that bank remains. We all know what happened to Anglo Irish Bank."
" . . . . I want to live in an Ireland of rights and responsibilities. My first question, therefore, is, how is it the responsibility of the Irish nation to pay €3.1 billion for Anglo Irish Bank promissory notes? Second, what right has the Government to take this on when it is obvious it is unfair? Third, is it fair that Irish people should pay for something in which they had no hand, act or part?
We are repeatedly and relentlessly told that the promissory notes scheme is the only means by which Ireland can get back on its own two feet and the backbone of the State, namely, the banks, can be saved. I believe the people are the backbone of this State and they should not be sacrificed for the greed, recklessness and self interest of others. More than enough has been asked of people. Asking the same people to pay more is, in my view, arrogant. Where is there a moral obligation on the State to pay this? Surely the moral obligation is to address the needs of the people. Where is the sense of moral obligation on the part of those individuals from the various banks and organisations, who are household names, to accept responsibility for what they have done? I would like to know if they are in any sense paying for what they have done and the mess they have created. They appear to have lost considerable wealth yet exist on incredible levels of income and resources. Many other people are making sacrifices and losing so much in terms of jobs and houses. We know the effects of this on people's mental and emotional health and how all of this contributes to their sense of powerlessness. . .
. . . . There is a carcass of a building in Dublin Central which was supposed to have been the headquarters of the new Anglo Irish Bank. Some people believe should it remain as a reminder of what can and does go wrong. It is interesting that the community which took on that bank remains. We all know what happened to Anglo Irish Bank."
05 February Technical Group Submission on Moore St. – January 2013
Click for full submission on Moore St Monument
This submission is being made by members of the Technical Group of the 31st Dáil.
Members did tour the site with the relatives and are making the following observations in the submission.
Dereliction/Significance:
There is no doubting the very considerable dereliction of the area around Moore St. It is a national disgrace that this area, the site of one of the most significant events in our history – Easter Rising, April 1916 - in fact a defining moment, has not been preserved appropriately, in a way that dignifies and acknowledges the work, the philosophies, the ideals, the heroism of the men and women who contributed to our independence and whose actions led to the foundation of the state, the Irish Republic.
The 1916 Rising is an unforgettable pivotal moment which embodies the dream of an Irish Republic and led to the foundation of the state.
01 February Joint Committee on the Implementation of the Good Friday Agreement
Ombudsman defends North's strip searches
Maureen attended Joint Committee on the Implementation of the Good Friday Agreement, where NI Prisoner Ombundsman presented.
"Marian Price’s detention was raised by Maureen O’Sullivan TD (Independent) by Maureen O’Sullivan TD (Independent) . . . . .Price (59), who served seven years for her part in the 1973 Old Bailey bombings and was released in 1980, was sent back to prison in May 2011 by the then Northern secretary, Owen Paterson. . . .
. . . According to figures from the Northern Irish Prison Service, there were 1,041 cases of solitary confinement in 2011 in a prison population of about 1,800, compared with 775 in 2010, 834 in 2009 and 959 in 2008."
(Click link on photo to read in full)
"Marian Price’s detention was raised by Maureen O’Sullivan TD (Independent) by Maureen O’Sullivan TD (Independent) . . . . .Price (59), who served seven years for her part in the 1973 Old Bailey bombings and was released in 1980, was sent back to prison in May 2011 by the then Northern secretary, Owen Paterson. . . .
. . . According to figures from the Northern Irish Prison Service, there were 1,041 cases of solitary confinement in 2011 in a prison population of about 1,800, compared with 775 in 2010, 834 in 2009 and 959 in 2008."
(Click link on photo to read in full)
31 January 2013 An Garda Síochána: Motion
Click to read Maureen's speech
Maureen spoke briefly on An Garda Síochána Motion, ' . . .
. . . I wish to look back 15 years to the situation in Dublin's inner city and the fractured relationship that existed then between the communities and the Garda. There was no trust and the only communication was very negative. However, an excellent initiative was drawn up over 13 years ago to address that and build relations between gardaí, the local authority and the communities. This was the Community Policing Forum, which has a full-time co-ordinator and two other staff. This initiative has been very successful in building trust and relations with the Garda through the community police and there is active engagement between gardaí and people living in those inner city communities, who know too well the effects of gangland crime and the scourge of drugs. . . . '
31 January Health Service Executive (Governance) Bill 2012: Second Stage
Click to read Maureen's speech in full
Maureen speaking on HSE and the Governance Bill, "When I was thinking about the health service, I tried to work out what word would best summarise it and I came up with "fraught". This is a service that has a massive budget yet it still has significant problems. It seems to totter from one crisis to another. I receive a considerable number of calls every day to do with health matters. This is not to take from the excellent care and service that health service staff provide to those who do get into the system. . . .
I refer to an article in the health supplement of The Irish Times yesterday (29 January 2013) which confirms what we already know, namely, the effect of poverty and unemployment on health. . . . . .
These health inequalities have been evident for far too long, as confirmed by one report after another, and in different parts of the world. The point is made that social injustice is killing people on a grand scale. People living in areas of high unemployment and deprivation engage in unhealthy behaviours because of the feelings of powerlessness they experience, exacerbated by the lack of educational attainment. These massive inequalities are not being addressed and the problem continues. . .
There has been much criticism of the HSE, some of which is justified, some not. . . . . . The programme for Government contains a grand plan for a health reform programme to bring about a universal, single-tier health service based on universal health insurance. It would be great to think the Bill would contribute to this. There are serious issues, some of which relate to recent decisions, that could be aided by the Bill and give more authority to the Minister. However, we know what happened in the case of the primary care centres. One area I represent, Summerhill in the north inner city, one of the most disadvantaged areas in Ireland, is still waiting for a primary care centre, although there is a move in the right direction. . . . . . . .
. . .The Technical Group introduced a Private Members' Bill last October. We asked the Minister to prioritise addiction services as a health rather than a criminal issue. It is positive that the issue of drug addiction comes within the responsibility of the Department of Health, but then one looks at the wide range of addictions and the associated mental, physical and emotional problems and illnesses, including suicide, homelessness, imprisonment, sexual violence and rape, as well as the socio-economic aspects. If I take the first six directorates, primary care, mental health, hospitals, social care, child and family services, health and well-being, addiction is related and relevant to each of them. The importance of addiction services will be further disjointed if they are covered by six bodies. There is a need for us to take this issue on board and address it. . .
. . . .I turn to the area of mental health and there is no doubting the need for a directorate. . . . The new director is crucial in this regard. It is recognised by everybody, especially those working in mental health services, that this function is needed to implement mental health policy. . .
. . . I support the mental health reform coalition which identified two urgently needed measures to ensure accountability for delivering policy, one being the appointment of an empowered competent director of mental health with a statutory duty to implement A Vision for Change. The functions of that director should be outlined in the Bill, as well as the provision that he or she consult users of mental health services, their families and other stakeholders."
I refer to an article in the health supplement of The Irish Times yesterday (29 January 2013) which confirms what we already know, namely, the effect of poverty and unemployment on health. . . . . .
These health inequalities have been evident for far too long, as confirmed by one report after another, and in different parts of the world. The point is made that social injustice is killing people on a grand scale. People living in areas of high unemployment and deprivation engage in unhealthy behaviours because of the feelings of powerlessness they experience, exacerbated by the lack of educational attainment. These massive inequalities are not being addressed and the problem continues. . .
There has been much criticism of the HSE, some of which is justified, some not. . . . . . The programme for Government contains a grand plan for a health reform programme to bring about a universal, single-tier health service based on universal health insurance. It would be great to think the Bill would contribute to this. There are serious issues, some of which relate to recent decisions, that could be aided by the Bill and give more authority to the Minister. However, we know what happened in the case of the primary care centres. One area I represent, Summerhill in the north inner city, one of the most disadvantaged areas in Ireland, is still waiting for a primary care centre, although there is a move in the right direction. . . . . . . .
. . .The Technical Group introduced a Private Members' Bill last October. We asked the Minister to prioritise addiction services as a health rather than a criminal issue. It is positive that the issue of drug addiction comes within the responsibility of the Department of Health, but then one looks at the wide range of addictions and the associated mental, physical and emotional problems and illnesses, including suicide, homelessness, imprisonment, sexual violence and rape, as well as the socio-economic aspects. If I take the first six directorates, primary care, mental health, hospitals, social care, child and family services, health and well-being, addiction is related and relevant to each of them. The importance of addiction services will be further disjointed if they are covered by six bodies. There is a need for us to take this issue on board and address it. . .
. . . .I turn to the area of mental health and there is no doubting the need for a directorate. . . . The new director is crucial in this regard. It is recognised by everybody, especially those working in mental health services, that this function is needed to implement mental health policy. . .
. . . I support the mental health reform coalition which identified two urgently needed measures to ensure accountability for delivering policy, one being the appointment of an empowered competent director of mental health with a statutory duty to implement A Vision for Change. The functions of that director should be outlined in the Bill, as well as the provision that he or she consult users of mental health services, their families and other stakeholders."
27 January Comments on Constitutional Convention January 2013 meeting:
Maureen's Convention address on Youth
And now all know that at least 3 of the 100 members of the convention are under 21
What percentage of population is under 21?
40% of the population of Ireland (all island, 6.1 million) is under 25,
21% of the population is under 15 & 19% of population is aged between 16 and 24
Yes, there seems to be under representation of younger people at the constitutional convention
and this is reflected throughout vast majority of representative structures in Ireland.
The inclusion of young people's direct participation has been raised on a number of occasions.
It was said in the plenary session, that voting won't be made compulsory & no one would go to gaol for not voting
If this was re-framed, it would make for an important point;
Have the people who go to prison, generally every voted or are considered regular voters?
It is not easy to ascertain, however it would be accepted that most of these individuals haven't ever voted or are not likely to be regular voters
and it is well-known that the prison populations in Ireland are mainly from lower socio-economic groups & working class communities.
What percentage of population is under 21?
40% of the population of Ireland (all island, 6.1 million) is under 25,
21% of the population is under 15 & 19% of population is aged between 16 and 24
Yes, there seems to be under representation of younger people at the constitutional convention
and this is reflected throughout vast majority of representative structures in Ireland.
The inclusion of young people's direct participation has been raised on a number of occasions.
It was said in the plenary session, that voting won't be made compulsory & no one would go to gaol for not voting
If this was re-framed, it would make for an important point;
Have the people who go to prison, generally every voted or are considered regular voters?
It is not easy to ascertain, however it would be accepted that most of these individuals haven't ever voted or are not likely to be regular voters
and it is well-known that the prison populations in Ireland are mainly from lower socio-economic groups & working class communities.
25 January Electoral (Dáil Constituencies) Bill 2012: Second Stage
Click to hear Maureen's speech in full
I wish to make a couple of points concerning this Bill. I will start by looking back at the 14 election campaigns in which I was involved with the late Tony Gregory in Dublin Central. I was thinking of the various changes in that constituency at different times. The East Wall area where I live, which to me is very much Dublin Cental, was out of the constituency at one stage, whereas areas such as Ballyfermot and Inchicore were included. On another occasion, we had the Fairview and Marino areas in Dublin Central, which are now in Deputy Finian McGrath's constituency.
The Bill before us proposes changes to Dublin Central, so I wish to examine how and why this is so. Another electoral commission is suggesting radical changes to Dublin Central, both in the area and number of seats. The Bill is supposed to be part of the agenda for political reform but there are more matters to examine in terms of political reform, particularly the work of the House and how we can make it more relevant and efficient. It must also be more representative of the Ireland we live in, including community issues.
The first step was to examine the work of Deputies to see exactly what we do and are supposed to be doing. Reform of the Oireachtas, including the work of Deputies, should have determined the number of Deputies required. While I may be somewhat cynical, I am just wondering about a pre-election promise to reduce the number of Deputies without examining what is needed. Real research into political reform should have happened first, including the work of Deputies. That might have indicated that we need even fewer Deputies than the proposed reduction of eight seats. It might also have considered other aspects because I am not too sure if the needs of constituencies were taken into account. It seems that a situation demanded by the Government drove the process, rather than the reform process, including Deputies' work, leading to the solution. It is like putting the cart before the horse, so that the evidence will fit the required result. Some €2.2 million is being saved by reducing Dáil membership but that sum could have been saved in other ways. We could have examined expenses and allowances, including those for leaders and political parties. We could also have examined pensions, which should have been addressed first, rather than what is happening with this legislation. . .
. . . I cannot finish my contribution without mentioning that I represent the Independent seat that was held for 27 years by, Tony Gregory, the longest serving Independent Deputy. Regardless of how people may feel about the late Mr. Gregory's politics or policies, I do not think there is any doubt about his integrity and the principled approach he took, based on fairness and social justice. What is happening in Dublin Central could be interpreted as a cute piece of social engineering to enable the sustainability of two other constituencies that do not have an Independent representation, at the potential cost of the longest held Independent seat in our history.
I am one of the Independent representatives on the Constitutional Convention, which is another example of putting the cart before the horse. That is another issue the convention could have taken on.
The Bill before us proposes changes to Dublin Central, so I wish to examine how and why this is so. Another electoral commission is suggesting radical changes to Dublin Central, both in the area and number of seats. The Bill is supposed to be part of the agenda for political reform but there are more matters to examine in terms of political reform, particularly the work of the House and how we can make it more relevant and efficient. It must also be more representative of the Ireland we live in, including community issues.
The first step was to examine the work of Deputies to see exactly what we do and are supposed to be doing. Reform of the Oireachtas, including the work of Deputies, should have determined the number of Deputies required. While I may be somewhat cynical, I am just wondering about a pre-election promise to reduce the number of Deputies without examining what is needed. Real research into political reform should have happened first, including the work of Deputies. That might have indicated that we need even fewer Deputies than the proposed reduction of eight seats. It might also have considered other aspects because I am not too sure if the needs of constituencies were taken into account. It seems that a situation demanded by the Government drove the process, rather than the reform process, including Deputies' work, leading to the solution. It is like putting the cart before the horse, so that the evidence will fit the required result. Some €2.2 million is being saved by reducing Dáil membership but that sum could have been saved in other ways. We could have examined expenses and allowances, including those for leaders and political parties. We could also have examined pensions, which should have been addressed first, rather than what is happening with this legislation. . .
. . . I cannot finish my contribution without mentioning that I represent the Independent seat that was held for 27 years by, Tony Gregory, the longest serving Independent Deputy. Regardless of how people may feel about the late Mr. Gregory's politics or policies, I do not think there is any doubt about his integrity and the principled approach he took, based on fairness and social justice. What is happening in Dublin Central could be interpreted as a cute piece of social engineering to enable the sustainability of two other constituencies that do not have an Independent representation, at the potential cost of the longest held Independent seat in our history.
I am one of the Independent representatives on the Constitutional Convention, which is another example of putting the cart before the horse. That is another issue the convention could have taken on.
24 January 'Government follows closely reports of human rights abuses of the Rohingya people'
Information about Rohingya & issues
Reply to Maureen's question on human rights abuses against the Rohingya people:
Question No. 197 Parliamentary Question - Dept Details
To ask the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he had, or intends to have, discussions with the Burmese Ambassador in relation to human rights abuses of the Rohingya people in Burma and if he will pursue this matter in his role on the Human Rights Council.
- Maureen O'Sullivan
Tuesday, 22nd January, 2013 For WRITTEN answer . Ref No: 3007/13
REPLY
The Government follows closely reports of human rights abuses of the Rohingya people in Burma/Myanmar and is concerned about the situation.
While Ireland’s diplomatic relations with Burma/Myanmar are maintained by secondary accreditation basis via our Embassy in Vietnam, and through the Embassy of Burma/Myanmar in London, we continue to work through the mechanisms of the EU and UN to ensure that human rights are respected in Burma/Myanmar and elsewhere.
Our Ambassador in Hanoi is due to present credentials in Burma/Myanmar as soon as dates are confirmed. Following accreditation, the issues raised by the Deputy will be discussed with the Burma/Myanmar authorities.
Ireland remains engaged at both European Union and international levels in monitoring the situation in Burma/Myanmar, including that of the Rohingya. Human rights have been a priority of successive Irish governments and are a key dimension of our foreign policy. Ireland, as an elected member of the Human Rights Council, will work closely with partners at the Council to ensure the continuation of international scrutiny of the human rights situation in Burma/Myanmar.
At the 67th session of the United Nations General Assembly Ireland along with our international partners urged the Government of Burma/Myanmar to accelerate its efforts to address human rights concerns and called upon the Government to grant safe, timely, full and unhindered access across Rakhine State.
Ireland stands ready to share its experiences and to assist the process of democratisation in Burma / Myanmar. Together with our EU colleagues, we want recent, positive, developments to bring lasting change for the people of Burma/Myanmar.
Ireland’s recent experience in Asia is relevant to Burma/Myanmar given our involvement in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia as well as in Timor Leste. We also actively engage in EU discussions to shape the priorities for European co-operation in development assistance with Burma/Myanmar. To date, Irish Aid has provided over €7m to Burma / Myanmar through NGOs and Irish missionaries for long term development and emergency and recovery responses.
Ireland shares the EU approach to areas of co-operation which include poverty reduction, in particular among ethnic minority groups, support for democratic transformation, rule of law, human rights, including the release of all remaining political prisoners, accountability and good governance, and support for electoral processes.
Question No. 197 Parliamentary Question - Dept Details
To ask the Tánaiste and Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade if he had, or intends to have, discussions with the Burmese Ambassador in relation to human rights abuses of the Rohingya people in Burma and if he will pursue this matter in his role on the Human Rights Council.
- Maureen O'Sullivan
Tuesday, 22nd January, 2013 For WRITTEN answer . Ref No: 3007/13
REPLY
The Government follows closely reports of human rights abuses of the Rohingya people in Burma/Myanmar and is concerned about the situation.
While Ireland’s diplomatic relations with Burma/Myanmar are maintained by secondary accreditation basis via our Embassy in Vietnam, and through the Embassy of Burma/Myanmar in London, we continue to work through the mechanisms of the EU and UN to ensure that human rights are respected in Burma/Myanmar and elsewhere.
Our Ambassador in Hanoi is due to present credentials in Burma/Myanmar as soon as dates are confirmed. Following accreditation, the issues raised by the Deputy will be discussed with the Burma/Myanmar authorities.
Ireland remains engaged at both European Union and international levels in monitoring the situation in Burma/Myanmar, including that of the Rohingya. Human rights have been a priority of successive Irish governments and are a key dimension of our foreign policy. Ireland, as an elected member of the Human Rights Council, will work closely with partners at the Council to ensure the continuation of international scrutiny of the human rights situation in Burma/Myanmar.
At the 67th session of the United Nations General Assembly Ireland along with our international partners urged the Government of Burma/Myanmar to accelerate its efforts to address human rights concerns and called upon the Government to grant safe, timely, full and unhindered access across Rakhine State.
Ireland stands ready to share its experiences and to assist the process of democratisation in Burma / Myanmar. Together with our EU colleagues, we want recent, positive, developments to bring lasting change for the people of Burma/Myanmar.
Ireland’s recent experience in Asia is relevant to Burma/Myanmar given our involvement in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia as well as in Timor Leste. We also actively engage in EU discussions to shape the priorities for European co-operation in development assistance with Burma/Myanmar. To date, Irish Aid has provided over €7m to Burma / Myanmar through NGOs and Irish missionaries for long term development and emergency and recovery responses.
Ireland shares the EU approach to areas of co-operation which include poverty reduction, in particular among ethnic minority groups, support for democratic transformation, rule of law, human rights, including the release of all remaining political prisoners, accountability and good governance, and support for electoral processes.
23 January Education (Welfare) Motion on 'Bullying'
Read Maureen's speech in full
Maureen speaking on DáilMotion relating to 'Bullying', "We know the consequences of bullying. It is not a recent phenomenon. Bullying has been with us since time immemorial. I do not know what it is in the human psyche that gives us this inclination, or need, to hurt a fellow human being.
There are two important words in the definition of bullying. They are "repeated" and "intentional". It is important not to blur the lines between having a disagreement, a row or a falling out and what is really bullying. If someone disagrees with me, it does not mean I am being bullied. The term "bullying" is sometimes applied to situations that are not bullying, as defined. This takes from the serious nature of bullying. . . .
. . . .Young people today do not have the language to express themselves. That is the first step in tackling bullying because they must be able to describe the feeling of being alienated and isolated."
There are two important words in the definition of bullying. They are "repeated" and "intentional". It is important not to blur the lines between having a disagreement, a row or a falling out and what is really bullying. If someone disagrees with me, it does not mean I am being bullied. The term "bullying" is sometimes applied to situations that are not bullying, as defined. This takes from the serious nature of bullying. . . .
. . . .Young people today do not have the language to express themselves. That is the first step in tackling bullying because they must be able to describe the feeling of being alienated and isolated."
18 January Further Education & Training Motion
Click to read speech in full here
Maureen speaking on Further Education & Training Private Members Motion
"My contribution will be based on my experience as a second level teacher who was closely involved with local post-leaving certificate colleges . . .
. . . . I always encouraged my students to consider post-leaving certificate courses as their plan A or plan B. Having attended many open day events with them, I know about the work done on such occasions. I always reminded my students to ask where people went after they did post-leaving certificate courses. The statistics in that regard were very positive. Many went directly into employment. They did not need to attend further education courses because they had secured particular qualifications. I support the ladder route introduced by the post-leaving certificate colleges whcih has been absolutely amazing. . . .
. . . . Second-chance education is even more important today. We are familiar with the statistics. While I do not want to see anybody losing his or her job or any course being withdrawn,
I will conclude by mentioning a statistic. In certain areas of Dublin Central only 18% of people advanced beyond primary education. That is a scandal. We have to look at that issue again.
"My contribution will be based on my experience as a second level teacher who was closely involved with local post-leaving certificate colleges . . .
. . . . I always encouraged my students to consider post-leaving certificate courses as their plan A or plan B. Having attended many open day events with them, I know about the work done on such occasions. I always reminded my students to ask where people went after they did post-leaving certificate courses. The statistics in that regard were very positive. Many went directly into employment. They did not need to attend further education courses because they had secured particular qualifications. I support the ladder route introduced by the post-leaving certificate colleges whcih has been absolutely amazing. . . .
. . . . Second-chance education is even more important today. We are familiar with the statistics. While I do not want to see anybody losing his or her job or any course being withdrawn,
I will conclude by mentioning a statistic. In certain areas of Dublin Central only 18% of people advanced beyond primary education. That is a scandal. We have to look at that issue again.
17 January Copyright protection in relation to the National Anthem ran out in December 2012
Click to enlarge
DÁIL QUESTION NO.95
To ask the Minister for Finance the steps he will take to ensure that the integrity of the National Anthem will be preserved as copyright will end in the near future; and if he will make a statement on the matter. - Maureen O'Sullivan.
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 16th January, 2013.
Ref No: 57867/12
REPLY
Minister for Finance ( Mr Noonan) : In response to the Deputy’s question I can confirm that copyright protection in relation to the National Anthem ran out in December 2012. The main purpose of ownership by the State of the copyright to the original version of the National Anthem was to ensure that it was freely available for general use. The situation in this regard has not changed with the expiry of copyright.
In relation to protecting the integrity of the National Anthem my Department will look at the possibility of introducing legislation should it be required to ensure that the National Anthem is not being used in an inappropriate context and without due deference such as to render it an object of scorn or derision.
To ask the Minister for Finance the steps he will take to ensure that the integrity of the National Anthem will be preserved as copyright will end in the near future; and if he will make a statement on the matter. - Maureen O'Sullivan.
* For WRITTEN answer on Wednesday, 16th January, 2013.
Ref No: 57867/12
REPLY
Minister for Finance ( Mr Noonan) : In response to the Deputy’s question I can confirm that copyright protection in relation to the National Anthem ran out in December 2012. The main purpose of ownership by the State of the copyright to the original version of the National Anthem was to ensure that it was freely available for general use. The situation in this regard has not changed with the expiry of copyright.
In relation to protecting the integrity of the National Anthem my Department will look at the possibility of introducing legislation should it be required to ensure that the National Anthem is not being used in an inappropriate context and without due deference such as to render it an object of scorn or derision.
